User blog comment:Carnarvan/Which Wiki Is Which?/@comment-26164274-20160411021556

how dO I WORDS To start off, I'm arguably terrible at arguments, debates, and anything that involves communicating with other people. I apologize in advance for any inconveniences my lack of coherency cause.

"Inspired from another book series" sounds too vague to me. I'm assuming you were more intending to address the "copying way too much from the book series"/borderline plagiarism. (I'm gonna call it borderline plagiarism.)

As someone who's a part of this dynamic, I confess that we have gone overboard with certain things. (i.e. Camp Half-blood location, relationships, etc.) It started out with me and Merista fangirling over the idea of having them here. It was with good intentions, but I guess they do pave the way to hell sometimes.

The only thing I feel that's kind of overexaggerated is the "ALL THE PERSONALITIES ARE THE EXACT FREAKING SAME." In my point of view, they are not.

Sveta is very un-Piperish with her fashion and being okay with manipulating people. Finlay is nothing like Jason as far as I can see. I don't see much Reyna in Calla. I haven't seen much of Rebecca yet, but the last time I checked her page, I remember her having this distinct 'feel' that wasn't Annabeth. I did my best to make my Nausikaa somewhat different from Thalia. She's a debater, is prone to think crap through before jumping, and awkwardly averse to the subject of romance.

I also want to point out something like this has been done before... Kibeth, SoA, Catty, Jaye, and I created French Aurors based off the Mortal Instruments series, specifically Clary Fray, Jace Lightwood, Alexander Lightwood, Isabelle Lightwood, and Simon Lewis.

Some of the characters are also seventeen now and sorta adults, but I'm guessing that's waaaay beside the point.

End thingy because I have no idea how to end this: It kinda hurts me to see people saying none of them original when some of the users who created them spent so much time (I myself spent a few good hours of my time developing Sikaa but lol never mind) working on them. *shrugs* Personal feelings aside, yeah, this issue does need to be resolved in a hopefully civil manner. I'm glad it's been brought back up to be finally resolved after the whole wikiwide dispute some time back. 🐑