User blog comment:Carnarvan/Which Wiki Is Which?/@comment-24830549-20160411011337

I agree that there is some serious plausibility issues here. But also, it seems like there hasn't really been any digressions from the plot of the Percy Jackson books. Same relationships, same nicknames, etc. I'd be okay with it if there were some minor personality nuances that led to different personality dynamics, but this just feels like "What if the CHB people came to Hogwarts?" No offense.